Crisis of natural-scientific and human approaches in psychiatry
https://doi.org/10.31363/2313-7053-2019-1-8-15
Abstract
The article is devoted to the problem of dualism of medicine as a whole and psychiatry, in particular, given that the psychiatry is a science, which includes both biological and humanitarian components. The issue of the contradictions between the concept of «evidence-based medicine» and the principles, on which humanitarian methods of treatment for mentally ill patients are based, is considered. It is concluded that developing a full-fledged theory of the biopsychosocial approach to the diagnosis and therapy of people with mental disorders is necessary.
About the Authors
N. G. Neznanov
V.M. Bekhterev National Research Medical Center for Psychiatry and Neurology
Russian Federation
Russian Federation
A. P. Kotsyubinsky
V.M. Bekhterev National Research Medical Center for Psychiatry and Neurology
Russian Federation
Russian Federation
D. A. Kotsyubinsky
Saint-Petersburg State University
Russian Federation
Russian Federation
References
1. AkzhigitovR.G. Borderline mental disorders / R.G. Akzhigitov // Medicinskajagazeta. –2001.—May—№37—[Electronicresource]—URL: http:// medgazeta.rusmedserv.com. (InRus.)
2. AleksandrovskiyJ.A. Borderline mental disorders/ J.A. Aleksandrovskiy—M.: GOETAR-Media.—2007.—720p. (In Rus)
3. Aleksandrovskiy J.A. Review of a book of A.B. Smulevich «Personality disorders. Trajectory in the space of a mental and somatic pathology»// Psikhiatriyaipsikhofarmakologiya. Zhurn. im. P.B. Gannushkina.—2012.—T.14.—№5.—P.45-46. (In Rus.)
4. Dunaevskiy V.V. About reprehensible stereotypes and militant dogmatism / V.V. Dunaevskiy// V.M. Bekhterev Review of Psychiatry and Medical Psychology—2018.—№2.—P.125-129. (In Rus.)
5. GurovitchI.J. Looking for new Approaches and Paradigms in Understanding psychosis/ I.J. Gurovich, N.G. Shashkova, O.O. Papsuev // Social’najaiklinicheskay apsikhiatriya.—2017.—T. 27.—№1—P.68-82. (In Rus.)
6. Zahar’inG.A. Clinical lectures and selected articles/ G.A. Zahar’in.—M.: PechatnjaA.I. Snegirevoj.—1910.—557p. (In Rus.)
7. Karvasarskiy B.D. Neuroses—the second edition, revised and updated / B.D. Karvasarskij.—M.: Medicina.—1990.—576p. (In Rus.)
8. KoposovN. E. Thewayhistoriansthink/ N. E. Koposov—M.: Novoeliteraturnoeobozrenie.—2001.—326p. (InRus.)
9. KotsyubinskyA.P. Multidimentional (holistic) diagnostic in psychiatry (biological, psychological and functional diagnosis) / A.P. Kotsyubinsky—Sankt-Peterburg: SpecLit,—2017.—285 p. (InRus.)
10. KotsyubinskyD.A. Humanitarias—they are psychotherapists in the absence of whom we are condemned to a collective neurosis/ D.A. Kotsyubinsky // Rosbalt—30.06.2018. [Electronicresource]—URL: http:// www.rosbalt.ru/piter/2018/06/30/1713968.html (In Rus.)
11. Limankin O.V. Problems and perspectives of deinstitutianalization and reform of in-patient psychiatry/ O.V. Limankin // Problemyiperspektivyr- azvitiyastatsionarnoypsikhiatritcheskoypomoschi (vdvuhtomakh).]—2009. -SPb.—V.1.—P.110-117. (In Rus.)
12. NeznanovN.G. ThevalueofV.M. Behterevschoolin- formationofbiopsychosocialconceptionofneuro- psychiatricdisorders/ N.G. Neznanov, M.A. Aki- menko, A.P. Kocjubinskij // Sib. Vestnikpsikhiatr. Inarkol.—2013.—№1.—P.77-81. (InRus.)
13. PolischukJ.I. Domination of the Biological and Neglect for the Psychosocial Direction in Russian Psychiatry / J.I. Polishhuk // Social’nayaiklinitcheskayapsikhiatriya. 2016.—№4.—P.71-74. (InRus.)
14. Retyunskiy K. J. Paliperidoneanditsprolongedformpaliperidonepalmitatepharmacokinetic characteristics / K.J. Retjunskij // Sovremennay aterapiyapsikhitcheskikhrasstroystv.—2012.—№2.—P. 25-32. (In Rus.)
15. HolmogorovaA.B. Clash of Paradigms in Mental Health Sciences: in Search of a way Out / A.B. Holmogorova // Social’nayaiklinitcheskayapsikhiatri ya—2014.—№4.—P.53-61. (In Rus.)
16. JastrebovV.S. The system-oriented model of psychoso- cial rehabilitation/ V.S. Jastrebov, V.G. MitikhinT.A. Solozinaidr. // Zhurn. nevrol. Ipsikhiatr. im. S.S. Korsakova.—2008.—№6.—P.4-10. (In Rus.)
17. Beck A.T. Schizophrenia: cognitive theory, research, and therapy / A.T. Beck, N.A. Rector, N. Stolar [et al.]—New York, London: The Guilford Press.—2008.—415p.
18. Dilthey W. Einleitung in die Geisteswissenschaften. Bd. 1.—Leipzig: Duncker& Humblot.—1883.
19. Engel G.L. Biopsychosocial model and medical education: who are to be the teacher? / G.L. Engel // N. Eng. Journ. Med.—1982.—Vol.306.—P.802- 805.
20. Garety P.A. A cognitive model of the positive symptoms of psychosis / P.A. Garety, E. Kuipers, D. Fowler et al. // Psychol. Med.—2001.—Vol.31.—Р.189-195.
21. Garety P.A. Implications for neurobiological research of cognitive models of psychosis: a theoretical paper / P.A. Garety, P. Bebbington, D. Fowler et al. // Psychol. Med.—2007.—Vol.37.—P.1377- 1391.
22. Grant P.M. Defeatist beliefs as a mediator of cognitive impairment, negative symptoms and functioning in schizophrenia / P.M. Grant, A.T. Beck // Schizophrenia Bull.—2009.—Vol.35.—P.798– 806.
23. Howes O.D. Schizophrenia: an integrated sociode- velopmental-cognitive model / O.D. Howes, R.M. Murray // Lancet.—2014.—Vol.383.—P.1677- 1687.
24. McGlashan T.H. The Psychosis-Risk Syndrome / T.H. McGlashan, B. Walsh, S. Wood // Hand- book for Diagnostic and Follow-up.—Oxford University Press, USA.—2010.—243p.
Review
For citations:
Neznanov N.G., Kotsyubinsky A.P., Kotsyubinsky D.A. Crisis of natural-scientific and human approaches in psychiatry. V.M. BEKHTEREV REVIEW OF PSYCHIATRY AND MEDICAL PSYCHOLOGY. 2019;(1):8-15. (In Russ.) https://doi.org/10.31363/2313-7053-2019-1-8-15
Views:
927
Email this article 