Genius Ideas and Genius Mistakes. (Non-material Nature of the Psyche, Part II)
https://doi.org/10.31363/2313-7053-2019-3-36-41
Abstract
The author develops ideas, which he presented in his paper Critical rethinking of the use of pharmacotherapy in mental disorders and critically analyses works by Descartes, I.М. Sechenov and I.P. Pavlov, which determined our methods of studying the psyche and treating mental disorders for many centuries. Reflexes of the Brain by I.M. Sechenov and ideas of the second signal system and higher nervous activity by I.P. Pavlov are analysed in detail. The author proves that these ideas, which still influence development of psychology, psychiatry, psychotherapy and social sciences, are fallacious.
References
1. Wiener N. Cybernetics, or control and communication in the animal and the machine). — Мoskva: Sovetskoe radio, 1968:325 (In Rus.).
2. Descartes R. Collected works. 2 volumes. Volume 1. — Мoskva: Misl, 1989:654 (In Rus.).
3. Lenin V.I. Collected works. The 4th edition, Volume 1. — Moskva: Gosudarstvennoe izdatelstvo politicheskoy literaturi, 1941-1967:127 (In Rus.).
4. Pavlov I.P. Collected works. Volumes 1-5. — Мoskva-Leningrad: Academiya nauk SSSR. — Tom III, Chast 1. 1949: 104, 323-340, 349 (In Rus.).
5. Reshetnikov M.M. Critical rethinking of the use of pharmacotherapy in mental disorders. Obozrenie psihiatrii I meditsinskoi psihologii im. V.M. Bekhtereva. 2017 : 17-21 (In Rus.).
6. Reshetnikov M.M. Psychodynamics and psychotherapy of depressions. St.Peterburg: Vostochno-Evropeisky Institut Psikhoanaliza, 2003 : 328 (In Rus.).
7. Reshetnikov M.M. Psychic trauma. St.Peterburg: Vostochno-Evropeisky Institut Psikhoanaliza, 2006 : 322. Second ed. — Moskva: Urait, 2018. (In Rus.).
8. Reshetnikov M.M. Psychic disorder. St.Peterburg: Vostochno-Evropeisky Institut Psikhoanaliza, 2008 : 272. Second ed. — Moskva: Urait. — 2017. (In Rus.).
9. Reshetnikov M.M. Critical postmaterialism in psychology and psychiatry. Nevrologicheskiy Buleten, Kazan, — Т. XLIII, Volume. 2. 2011 : 66—69 (In Rus.).
10. Reshetnikob M.M. Ideas live their own life. Psikhoterapia. # 8 (189), 2018 : 44-50 (In Rus.).
11. Sechenov I.M. Reflexes of the brain. — Мoskva: Ministerstvo prosvyastcheniya SSSR, 1953 : 31, 32, 33, 36, 37, 117 (In Rus.).
12. Terekhov P.G. Sechenov I.M. and materialist psychology. — Moskva: Academiya nauk SSSR. — 1957: 55-109 (In Rus.).
13. Lapin I. P., Oxenkrag G. F. Intensification of the central serotoninergic processes as a possible determinant of thymoleptic effect. — Lancet. — 1969. — N1. — P.132-136.
14. Reshetnikov M.M. What is the Psyche? What are we Curing? — Journ. Anthropology. — 2017. — Vol.6. — P.11-15.
15. Reshetnikov M.M. Problem of Relation between Brain and Mind in Physiology, Medicine and Psychology. — Journ. of Psychiatry and Psychiatric Disorders. — 2017. — Vol.1. — P.313-316.
16. Reshetnikov M.M. During Two Thousand Years We Were Looking for the Psyche in a Wrong Place (Ideas Live Their Own Life). — International Journal of Current Innovations in Advanced Research. — 2018. — Vol.1. — P.82-87.
17. Reshetnikov M.M. Non-material Nature of the Psyche. Psychological Review. — American Psychological Association. — 2018. — Vol.125. — P.1035-1047.
Review
For citations:
Reshetnikov M.M. Genius Ideas and Genius Mistakes. (Non-material Nature of the Psyche, Part II). V.M. BEKHTEREV REVIEW OF PSYCHIATRY AND MEDICAL PSYCHOLOGY. 2019;(3):36-41. (In Russ.) https://doi.org/10.31363/2313-7053-2019-3-36-41
Views:
864
Email this article 